The Mystery Writer by Sulari Gentill

*** Review ***

Sulari Gentill’s latest offering, The Mystery Writer, is a literary thriller that not only captivates readers with its intriguing plot but also challenges the very nature of storytelling. Theodosia Benton, our unconventional protagonist, abandons the expected trajectory of her life to pursue her passion for writing, setting the stage for a narrative that blurs the lines between reality and fiction.

The story begins with Theo’s unexpected arrival at her brother Gus’s doorstep, a move that sets in motion a series of events that will change the course of her life. The narrative takes unexpected turns when Theo’s mentor, the highly successful author Dan Murdoch, is brutally murdered. What follows is a complex and multi-layered mystery that immerses readers in the enigmatic world of literary conspiracies, where a writer’s voice becomes a weapon and identity is a malleable construct.

Gentill skillfully weaves a tale that keeps readers on the edge of their seats, introducing eccentric doomsday conspiracy theorists who monitor the protagonists’ every move. The tension builds as Theo, determined to find justice for her mentor, becomes entangled with zealous fans, a nosy journalist, and a perilous web of powerful individuals. The stakes are high as Theo’s dream of becoming a writer unwittingly drags her and her loved ones into treacherous territory.

The strength of The Mystery Writer lies not only in its intricate plot but also in its well-developed characters. Theo’s relationship with her brother Gus adds a layer of realism and warmth to the narrative, showcasing the bonds of familial love and protection. The author masterfully portrays the dynamics between siblings, adding depth to the story.

The writing style, though slow to start, gradually picks up pace in the second half, creating a sense of anticipation and urgency. Gentill manages to maintain the suspense without relying on gratuitous gore, offering readers a murder mystery without the typical trappings of the genre. The story unfolds with a careful balance of intrigue and character development, ensuring that even the side characters are well-fleshed-out and contribute meaningfully to the narrative.

For readers who appreciate a cozy mystery thriller involving authors and writers, The Mystery Writer is a delightful choice. It caters to those who prefer a more relaxed pace, steering away from the stressful and hardcore fast-paced thrillers. The novel’s strength lies in its ability to appeal to a broad audience, with a plot that combines mystery, family dynamics, and the world of literature.

One notable aspect is the portrayal of the eccentric Etheridge Family, a group of conspiracy theorists that adds a unique layer to Theo’s journey. The revelation about her friend, private investigator Mac Etheridge, being part of this family introduces a compelling dynamic, making the narrative even more intriguing.

While the book may lack a gasp-out-loud twist towards the end, the explanation provided is thoughtful and satisfying. Gentill ensures a good closure for the story, leaving readers with a sense of fulfillment. The journey through the labyrinth of literary conspiracies is a rollercoaster ride, and the final chapter delivers a brilliant conclusion that ties up the loose ends with finesse.

In conclusion, The Mystery Writer is a well-crafted literary thriller that challenges conventional notions of storytelling. Sulari Gentill’s ability to blend mystery, family dynamics, and the world of literature makes this novel a compelling read. Whether you’re a fan of cozy mysteries, realistic sibling relationships, or enigmatic conspiracy theories, this book offers a rich and satisfying experience. So, if you’re ready for a journey into the labyrinth of words and secrets, pick up The Mystery Writer and embark on a rollercoaster ride that will keep you guessing until the very end.