The Butterfly Collector by Tea Cooper

*** Review ***

Tea Cooper’s The Butterfly Collector is a delightful literary journey through time, seamlessly blending history, mystery, and the art of storytelling. As I dove into this novel, I found myself captivated by two seemingly unrelated timelines, each with its unique set of characters and mysteries. However, as the pages turned, the intricate threads of the plot began to weave together, creating a tapestry of intrigue that left me utterly spellbound.

In 1868, we are introduced to Theodora Breckenridge, a young woman mourning the tragic loss of her family. Theodora’s heart is firmly set on her passion for botanical illustration, and she aspires to follow in the footsteps of the renowned Scott sisters, who once lived nearby. Her discovery of a rare butterfly species in Australia sets the stage for a scientific breakthrough that could change her life forever. Theodora’s journey is beautifully complemented by her relationship with Clarrie, her maid, whose life takes a dramatic turn when her newborn son goes missing. This event sets in motion a series of events that will ripple through time.

Fast forward to 1922 in Sydney, where Verity Binks, an aspiring journalist, is navigating the challenges of a world dominated by men returning from the war. When Verity receives an enigmatic invitation to the Sydney Artists Masquerade Ball, along with a stunning butterfly costume, her curiosity is piqued. As she delves into the history of the Treadwell Foundation, an institution dedicated to supporting unmarried women and their babies, Verity uncovers a web of secrets and connections that spans half a century. Cooper skillfully guides us through Verity’s investigation, revealing hidden family ties and long-buried truths that add layers of complexity to the narrative.

What struck me most about The Butterfly Collector is Cooper’s ability to breathe life into her characters. Theodora, Clarrie, and Verity are all distinct and compelling individuals, each with their own aspirations, fears, and desires. The author masterfully intertwines their stories, making it a challenging task to keep track of the intricate web of relationships, but one that proves immensely rewarding.

Cooper’s writing is both evocative and informative. Her meticulous research shines through as she seamlessly incorporates historical facts about Australia’s flora, fauna, and social dynamics into the narrative. The vivid descriptions of the natural world and the allure of botanical illustration were particularly captivating, transporting me to the enchanting landscapes of 19th-century Morpeth.

While I thoroughly enjoyed The Butterfly Collector, there were a few aspects that left me wanting more. Verity and Arlo’s relationship, for instance, felt somewhat rushed and could have benefited from more development. Additionally, the story’s final revelation left me with unanswered questions and a sense of ambiguity that, while reflective of real-life mysteries, left me yearning for a more satisfying resolution.

In conclusion, The Butterfly Collector is a book that immerses you in a world of historical intrigue, art, and family secrets. Tea Cooper’s narrative prowess shines as she skillfully weaves together two timelines into a tapestry of mystery and discovery. The characters are richly developed, and the historical context is brought to life with vivid descriptions and meticulous research. While the ending may have left a few loose ends, it doesn’t detract from the overall enjoyment of this captivating novel. I wholeheartedly recommend The Butterfly Collector to anyone who relishes a blend of history, mystery, and the intricacies of human relationships. This book is a testament to Cooper’s storytelling finesse and her ability to transport readers to another time and place.