Same As It Ever Was by Claire Lombardo

*** Review ***

Claire Lombardo’s Same As It Ever Was is a profound exploration of the complexities of family life and the labyrinthine paths of personal growth. At its core, the novel tells the story of Julia Ames, a 57-year-old woman who appears to have finally achieved the stability she long craved. However, this stability is soon tested by a series of unexpected events that force her to confront her past and reassess her present.

Julia’s life has never been straightforward. From a tumultuous youth filled with emotional upheavals, she has now reached a point where she feels in control, ensconced in the privileges of her middle-class existence. Yet, as life often does, it throws her a curveball. Her seemingly steady son makes a surprising announcement, her teenage daughter begins to pull away, and an old friend reappears, bringing with her a flood of memories and unresolved issues. Lombardo skillfully navigates these events, illustrating how the past and present intertwine to shape our lives.

The book delves deeply into the nature of relationships, particularly the maternal bond. Julia’s interactions with her children, Ben and Alma, are fraught with tension and love. Ben, at 24, is making life choices that mirror his mother’s past, prompting Julia to reflect on her own decisions and their repercussions. Alma, on the other hand, is the typical rebellious teenager, challenging Julia’s patience and understanding. Lombardo captures the essence of maternal ambivalence, the simultaneous love and frustration that defines the parent-child relationship.

One of the most compelling aspects of Same As It Ever Was is its character-driven narrative. The plot progresses not through grandiose events but through the subtle, often painful evolution of its characters. Julia’s journey is one of self-discovery and acceptance, a path that many readers will find relatable. Her life is a testament to the fact that growth and change are possible at any stage, even when the road is rocky and uncertain.

The novel also touches on themes of mental health and self-sabotage. Julia’s struggles are portrayed with empathy and realism, making her a deeply human character. Her traumatic childhood, which she frequently references, adds layers to her personality and helps explain her present anxieties. This nuanced portrayal of mental health issues is one of the strengths of Lombardo’s writing, offering readers a compassionate and honest depiction of the challenges many face.

Lombardo’s writing is rich and descriptive, bringing to life the world Julia inhabits. From the luxurious grocery store where she encounters Helen Russo, to the intimate moments of self-reflection, the settings are vividly painted, immersing readers in the story. The detailed descriptions add depth to the narrative, making the characters and their experiences feel real and tangible.

However, the book is not without its flaws. At 512 pages, it is a lengthy read, and some chapters can feel slow-paced. The constant switching between past and present timelines, while effective in illustrating the interconnectedness of Julia’s experiences, can also be jarring at times. Additionally, the story’s focus on a wealthy, privileged family might not resonate with all readers, and there are moments where a deeper exploration of Julia’s childhood would have added to the narrative.

Despite these minor drawbacks, Same As It Ever Was remains a powerful and engaging novel. It is a testament to Lombardo’s skill as a writer that she can create such complex, believable characters and weave their stories into a compelling whole. The book’s exploration of familial dynamics and personal growth is both heart-wrenching and uplifting, capturing the essence of what it means to navigate the highs and lows of life.

In conclusion, Claire Lombardo has once again proven herself to be a master of the family drama. Same As It Ever Was is a beautifully crafted novel that delves into the intricacies of relationships and the impact of our past on our present. It is a story that will resonate with many, offering a poignant reminder that even in the midst of life’s chaos, there is always the possibility for growth and redemption. If you enjoyed Lombardo’s previous work, The Most Fun We Ever Had, this latest offering is sure to captivate you. Despite its length, the journey with Julia Ames is one worth taking, filled with moments that will make you cheer, cry, and reflect on your own life’s path.