Pretend You’re Mine by Lucy Score

*** My Review ***

Lucy Score’s “Pretend You’re Mine,” the first book in the Benevolence series, captivates readers with its small-town charm and heartwarming romance. Harper, a survivor with an optimistic outlook on life, and Luke, a man trying to avoid romantic entanglements after a personal tragedy, find themselves drawn to each other despite their initial resistance. As their story unfolds, Score expertly weaves together a tale of found families, second chances, and the power of love.

Unfolding within the familiar framework of the fake dating trope, this book spun its own unique tale, weaving a tapestry of shared beds and undeniable sparks that inevitably flew between Luke and Harper. Yet, their burgeoning emotions presented a complex struggle, particularly for Luke, as the weight of his past burdened him more heavily than it did Harper. Their journey unfolded against the backdrop of his deployment and subsequent return, offering glimpses into their intertwined lives. However, as the narrative progressed, Luke’s tragic history morphed him into an enormous jerk, compelling the entire community of Benevolence to intervene.

Harper, as a character, captivated me with her unyielding resilience and refusal to tolerate any nonsense. She was a true survivor, embodying a badass spirit that resonated with me. Nonetheless, there were moments when her actions struck me as slightly vexing or detached from reality. On the other hand, Luke’s character was undeniably flawed, yet he possessed redeeming qualities that brought a sense of fulfillment. The presence of a multitude of secondary characters, coupled with the intimate small-town atmosphere, heightened the book’s overall ambiance and contributed to its undeniable charm, amplifying the pleasure it brought.

The town of Benevolence serves as an endearing backdrop, populated by delightful and quirky side characters who add depth to the narrative. While Luke gradually thaws throughout the book, it is Harper who steals the spotlight. Her positive demeanor and town therapist-like qualities make her a lovable and relatable protagonist. Score’s ability to portray both pain and angst is commendable, as she explores the complexities of the characters’ emotions.

The chemistry between Luke and Harper is palpable, and their journey from pretending to be in a relationship to realizing their true feelings is a delight to witness. The author’s skillful portrayal of the small-town ambiance and the fake dating trope adds to the enjoyment of the story. The book’s length is hardly noticeable, as readers will find themselves effortlessly engrossed in the narrative, unable to put it down.

The authentic portrayal of pain and angst in “Pretend You’re Mine” further enhances the emotional depth of the story. While Luke initially struggles to open himself up to love again, his journey toward self-discovery and redemption is a compelling aspect of the book. Score skillfully demonstrates the transformation of his character, gradually shedding the barriers he has built around himself. Despite his initial shortcomings, witnessing Luke’s realization of his love for Harper is gratifying, even if it comes close to being too late.

The theme of unconditional love resonates throughout the narrative, highlighting the power of forgiveness and the importance of seizing happiness when it presents itself. The dynamic between Harper and Luke is complemented by a supporting cast of endearing side characters who contribute to the charm of the small town setting. Score adeptly weaves their stories together, making readers feel like a part of the tightly-knit community where everyone knows everyone’s business.

Despite the considerable distance that separated the main characters throughout much of the story, the plot unfolded at a steady pace, effortlessly maintaining the reader’s engagement. This lighthearted tale thrived on its ability to keep stakes relatively low, ensuring an entertaining and pleasurable experience.

For those contemporary romance enthusiasts seeking a dash of spice, I wholeheartedly recommend this book. While it indulges in passionate moments, the story does not solely rely on explicit content, as a well-crafted plot still takes center stage. It gracefully avoids falling into the realm of mere smut, offering readers a delightful balance of sensual allure and narrative substance.

The book is a page-turner from beginning to end, drawing readers in with its blend of heartwarming romance, engaging plot twists, and vividly crafted scenes. The chemistry between Harper and Luke is palpable, their interactions filled with a sweet and sassy banter that keeps readers hooked. Score’s ability to create an immersive reading experience makes “Pretend You’re Mine” a standout in the genre of small town and fake dating romances.

“Pretend You’re Mine” is a book that evokes a range of emotions, leaving readers in an “ooey gooey puddle” of satisfaction. It beautifully captures the themes of unconditional love, forgiveness, and the importance of seizing opportunities before it’s too late. With a perfect balance of humor, heart, and steamy romance, Score delivers a captivating tale that will leave readers eagerly anticipating the next installment in the series. Fans of small town romances and fake dating tropes will undoubtedly find themselves immersed in the captivating world of Benevolence and eagerly awaiting the next installment in the series.