Only If You’re Lucky by Stacy Willingham

*** Review ***

Stacy Willingham’s latest psychological thriller, Only If You’re Lucky, unfolds a tale of friendship, envy, and betrayal against the backdrop of a liberal arts college in South Carolina. Having been captivated by Willingham’s previous works, A Flicker in the Dark and All The Dangerous Things, I eagerly delved into her latest offering with high expectations. The novel introduces us to Margot, a reserved freshman haunted by the recent loss of her best friend, Eliza. Willingham skillfully crafts the narrative, blending a slow burn with the intensity of dark academia, reminiscent of a fusion between “Heathers” and “Pretty Little Liars.”

Margot’s encounter with the magnetic Lucy Sharpe at the end of their freshman year becomes the catalyst for a gripping story. Lucy, bold and dangerous, draws Margot into a world of friendship, secrets, and a shared off-campus house with two other girls—Sloane, the sarcastic one, and Nicole, the nice one. As Margot begins to emerge from her shell, a sinister undercurrent takes hold when a fraternity boy is brutally murdered, and Lucy goes missing without a trace.

The novel adeptly explores the nuances of friendship, loyalty, and the thin line between envy and admiration. Willingham’s portrayal of unreliable female characters concealing hidden truths adds complexity to the narrative, keeping readers on the edge of their seats. Margot’s journey, haunted by the ghost of Eliza, is juxtaposed against the eerie atmosphere of a college setting, creating a captivating tension.

The pacing of Only If You’re Lucky is a testament to Willingham’s storytelling prowess. While the initial chapters build a foundation for the characters and their relationships, the narrative gradually intensifies, leading to shocking revelations. The alternating timelines, revealing the disappearances of Lucy and another key character, Levi, add a layer of mystery and suspense.

As a reader familiar with Willingham’s previous works, the thematic elements of revenge, jealousy, and the dark complexities of friendship are trademarks that resonate. However, Only If You’re Lucky takes a slightly different direction, presenting a slower burn that may be challenging for those expecting the breakneck pace of her earlier novels. The college setting and characters, while expertly portrayed, might be less relatable for some readers.

Margot’s internal struggles, the intricate dynamics among the roommates, and the fraternity event that unravels a new tragedy contribute to a storyline that, despite its slower pace, is rich in depth. The ending, while described as over-the-top by some, adds a layer of unpredictability, challenging readers to reassess their assumptions.

Willingham’s writing style is a highlight, with her ability to drop subtle clues at precisely the right moments. The narrative is not only a psychological thriller but also a treasure hunt for hidden Easter eggs, a testament to the author’s meticulous planning. As an active reader, uncovering these clues added an extra layer of enjoyment, highlighting Willingham’s talent for weaving intricate details into her storytelling.

In conclusion, Only If You’re Lucky may deviate from the rapid intensity of Willingham’s previous works, but it stands as a testament to her ability to craft a compelling psychological thriller. The novel explores the dark underbelly of friendship, infusing the college setting with suspense and mystery. While the pacing may not suit all readers, those who appreciate a slower burn with well-developed characters and unexpected twists will find this novel a worthy addition to Willingham’s repertoire. As I eagerly await her next offering, Only If You’re Lucky reaffirms Stacy Willingham’s status as a master storyteller in the realm of psychological suspense.