Dark Water Daughter by H. M. Long

*** Review ***

Dark Water Daughter, the first installment in the Winter Sea series by H. M. Long presents an exhilarating Jacobean escapade set on the vast oceans, brimming with enchantment, deceit, salvation, and formidable female characters. This action-packed novel captures the same vibe and atmosphere as Pirates of the Caribbean, immersing readers in a dashing sea-faring adventure full of peril, treasure, and fascinating magic.

The story follows Mary Firth, a Stormsinger, whose voice possesses the power to still hurricanes and shatter armadas. Forced into servitude under the pirate lord Silvanus Lirr, Mary seeks protection from his arch-rival in exchange for her skills. However, her new ally harbors a vendetta of his own. Meanwhile, Samuel Rosser, a dishonored naval officer stationed on The Hart, a notorious privateer vessel, is resolute in apprehending Lirr and reclaiming his reputation. The paths of Mary and Samuel intertwine as they navigate the treacherous waters of revenge and loyalty, battling forces older and more powerful than the pirates who seek to enslave them.

One of the book’s positive aspects is the captivating magical system. The various magical affinities in the story are wonderfully crafted, and learning how they work and interact with one another is one of the highlights of the story. Long skillfully integrates the magic into the narrative, allowing it to play a significant role in the characters’ lives and the overall plot. Mary’s Stormsinger abilities are both awe-inspiring and haunting, adding a layer of mystique to her character.

The multiple, mostly dual point of view adds depth and complexity to the story. While primarily following Mary’s perspective, the occasional flashbacks provide insight into her journey from a stormsinger in hiding to a convicted highwayman about to face her punishment. These glimpses into her past not only flesh out her character but also add emotional weight to her actions and decisions throughout the narrative. Samuel’s point of view, on the other hand, provides a contrasting viewpoint and showcases his own motivations and struggles. The dual POV effectively enhances the overall storytelling and keeps the readers engaged.

Mary herself is a standout character. Feisty and unapologetic, she commands attention whenever she appears on the page. Her determination, resilience, and skill as a stormsinger make her a compelling protagonist. The character development throughout the book is excellent, and Mary’s growth as she navigates the challenges and dangers she faces is a joy to witness. The supporting cast is equally well-crafted, with a large ensemble of characters who each have their own distinct personalities and stories. Long takes the time to flesh out these characters, making them feel like real people with their own hopes, fears, and motivations.

The historical detail in Dark Water Daughter is also commendable. While set in a secondary world, Long draws inspiration from the 17th-century analogues, creating a vivid and immersive backdrop for the story. The clothing, manners, and societal mindset of the characters are well-researched and expertly portrayed. The author’s attention to detail adds depth and authenticity to the world-building, making it easier for readers to suspend their disbelief and fully immerse themselves in the story.

The book is set in Tampa Bay, a unique and intriguing setting for a fantasy novel. Long’s descriptive prose brings the location to life, capturing the beauty and danger of the high seas. The reader can almost feel the salty air, taste the brine on their lips, and hear the creaking of the ships as they sail through the waters. The attention to detail in the setting enhances the overall reading experience and adds to the sense of adventure and exploration.

The pacing of the story is engaging, with a good balance between character development and plot progression. Long skillfully weaves together the personal journeys of the characters with the larger narrative, creating a compelling and well-rounded story. The world-building is exceptional, with unique lore and a rich mythology that adds depth and complexity to the world. Long takes the time to establish the rules and boundaries of the magical system, allowing readers to fully understand and appreciate its impact on the story.

Dark Water Daughter also excels in its portrayal of relationships, particularly between the main characters. Mary’s relationship with Samuel is wholesome and near perfect, adding a layer of tenderness and vulnerability to her otherwise fierce and independent character. Their connection feels genuine and develops organically throughout the story, complementing the main plot without overshadowing it.

However, there are a few drawbacks to be mentioned. Some readers may find the occasional info-dumping regarding certain characters and their relationships with others to be overwhelming. While the book provides a large cast of characters, the extensive information about their pasts and connections can be challenging to absorb at times. Additionally, there are a few unanswered questions, which may leave some readers craving more closure or further exploration in subsequent books.

In conclusion, Dark Water Daughter is an enthralling and thrilling fantasy novel that captures the essence of a swashbuckling adventure on the high seas. With its rich character development, excellent world-building, and unique blend of magic and piracy, this book is a must-read for fans of action-packed fantasy tales. Although it can be enjoyed as a standalone, it also serves as a promising start to the Winter Sea series. H. M. Long has crafted a captivating story that will keep readers turning the pages, eagerly awaiting the next installment.